Do Smart Guys Tell Better Jokes?

In the wake of the recent blog brouhaha over IQ and the Wealth of Nations I have been thinking about the general connection between intelligence and income.

My interpretation is that many people find it natural to conclude that IQ causes macroeconomic growth because IQ appears to cause microeconomic success. High IQ people are richer people, on average.

While I am sure that many smart people are quick to assert that their intelligence is what got them where they are, are we so sure? Height is correlated with individual success. I willing to bet height is also correlated with economic growth. And, we know that there is a height “Flynn effect.” That is, people have been getting taller over time. Do we think height causes growth?

The height correlation is usually settled by noting that height is a general sign of health and fitness, thus the correlation with macroeconomic growth, and therefore tall people are more likely to be chosen as spouses of successful people. Rich men and women have a greater choice in spouse and they tend to choose taller ones. Therefore, height and the genetic or cultural traits that produce wealth are commingled.

Could the same thing be true with IQ? That is, are smarter people more likely to be chosen as spouses to the rich and powerful? Now one possibility is that intelligence is just out and out attractive. Some people may agree with that conjecture.

Another, however, is that intelligent people are more likely to land a successful spouse because they are more clever at the dating game. My pet theory is that the human brain evolved through sexual selection. It’s just too big and mostly useless to have come about any other way. Looking at the monstrous and dangerous thing sitting a top most people’s shoulders one cannot help but be reminded of the Irish Elk.

It wasn’t so much that we impressed each other with our big brains, but that those brains busied themselves with devious plots to ensnare the objects of our affections. Most of us are aware of the modal thought among men and I would reason a guess that the modal thought among women is the dissection of the thoughts and intentions of men.

It seems possible then that IQ may simply be commingled with the attributes that produce success. My guess is that those attributes have more to do with perspiration than inspiration.